Ah...it's springtime and the smell of first communion is in the air, don't you think? Unfortunately, that smell is closer to the sweaty armpits of anxious parents than it is to the sweet smell of our Lord.
Just around this time each year I get inundated with requests for seating, questions about clothing, concerns about pictures, and requests for present ideas. Any requests for information about the Body and Blood of Our Lord and Savior? Not a one.
Well, except for this one, disguised as a parental concern: "Should they drink the wine? Isn't that Illegal?"
Oye Vey.
Let's dispatch with the legality question first, and then address the heart of the issue, shall we?
With regard to drinking "the wine," because it happens in the context of a religious practice and because the parents are (presumably) present and consenting, it is, in fact, perfectly legal for your 7 year old to have a sip.
But the real issue here is "the wine." Most parents don't have a problem with the legality issue so much as with the connotations they associate with alcohol, and especially young people drinking alcohol.
In the past I've tried talking about the substance and accidents of transubstantiation ("What's 'curly red,' without the hair?"). I've tried the sign and symbol language ("A symbol makes a reality present, just like your living body makes you present."). Neither go over very well.
But this reflection seems to help. Try it!
First ask yourself two questions:
What are the meanings or images that you associate with bread? (Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, Wonder bread, and a nice baguette, perhaps.)
What do you think of when you think of Jesus? (God, Loves us, died for us, etc.)
So here's the explanation: When you receive the Body of Christ, what are you thinking? Wonder bread or Jesus? For most of us, it's "Jesus." When we say that the bread and wine truly become the body and blood of Jesus, part of what that means is that the Eucharist transforms the images and meanings of this everyday thing, bread, into the meanings and images that we associate with Jesus. "Wonder bread" out, "Jesus who died for us" in! This same principle applies to the wine, but because so many of us did not receive the Blood of Jesus as children, we never made the connection. So let's try it again:
What do you think of when you think of alcohol? (You might have a whole range of thoughts here, from alcoholism to a nice glass of Pinto Noir.)
What do you think of when you think of Jesus? (Loving savior, light of the world, etc)
Let's repeat: the Eucharist is a transformation "the wine" and all the meanings we associate with "alcohol" to the Blood of Christ, and all the meanings we associate with Jesus. It may not transform the chemical component, but it transforms how we think about what we're drinking.
That being said, both species (the Body and the Blood) are considered complete in and of themselves. You don't have to have both of them to have communion. God is just a generous guy and goes all out. But either one works. (This is good news for recovering alcoholics or those with Celiac disease, but bad news for recovering alcoholics with Celiac disease.)
But! If you don't receive the Blood, don't just walk on by like Jesus isn't there! Would you just walk past the Body? No! If Jesus was standing there, waving, would you hurry past, head down, and pretend you didn't see him? Never! So, just as you bow or genuflect to the Body of Christ, if you do not receive the Blood of Christ, at least say hello by taking a moment to bow before you pass. Finally, if you are still struggling with this "the wine is Jesus" business, I encourage you, all the more, to bow. The physical practice of honoring the Blood might eventually move your heart and mind into belief. That's a little church trick we like to call ''Lex Orandi, Lex Credendi."
In other news, Carolina Cannonball over at The Crescat has nominated me for "Best Heretical Blog," which I will choose to take as a compliment as she is both a regular reader and a Republican. That must be painful. Anyhoo, voting begins on April 1st, and sending a bunch of San Francisco Hippie Catholics her way might be fun. Just keep repeating to yourself, "The Church is big enough for both of us," and go vote. :)